Skip to content

Rob Voyle

That new house did not settle. It was built out of level.

I have stood in houses less than a year old with more than 120 mm of fall from one end to the other. The door frames were level. The kitchen was level. The house had not dropped. It had been built like that. Settlement is the word that gets used when nobody has taken a baseline.

A new house can move a bit. Plaster dries. The slab cures. The ground takes the weight of the building. I am not arguing with that. A hairline in the first months, a door that needed one adjustment, a joint that was filled and stayed filled: that can be ordinary, and it should be finished early. It should not still be "settlement" in the last year of the warranty.

What I keep seeing is the other use of the word. The owner rings the builder. Someone comes out with filler, calls it natural settlement, and leaves. If the crack opens again, the same bloke comes back. Nothing has been measured. The crack is just clean until the next time, and the warranty clock is running while that happens.

The 120 mm house that had not moved

I have levelled houses that were not yet 12 months old and found more than 120 mm difference from one end of the building to the other. On the numbers alone, that looks serious. Then you look at the door frames, the cabinetry, the robe shelves. They are level. They were installed to the floor that was already there.

That house was built out of level. The slab was out when the frame went up, and the fit-out followed the slab. It did not drop 120 mm after the kitchen went in. If it had, the doors would be racked and the cabinets would be out of square. They were not. A builder calling that settlement is describing the way it was built, not movement since handover.

One set of levels cannot tell you that by itself. The levels tell you the shape today. The doors and the cabinets tell you whether the shape was already there when they were fitted. The thing that actually settles the argument is a baseline: levels taken at handover, before the first maintenance visit, before anyone fills a crack. The next survey is then a comparison. Without that first survey, everyone is guessing, and the guess usually favours the person who wants the warranty to expire.

If you missed handover, get the levels done now and keep them. That survey becomes the baseline. It will not tell you what happened last winter. It will tell you what happens next.

The ones that have actually moved

The other house is obvious once you stop looking only at the floor. Doors that used to close. A cabinet that has pulled away. A crack the maintenance crew filled, split open again along the same line. Stair-step joints in the brick. A gap at the garage slab that was not in the handover photos. That is movement since the house was finished.

On a sand pad I am usually looking at fill that was not compacted properly, then got wet. A leaking pipe, a soakwell too close, drainage dumped against the slab. That corner is dropping. It is not the house "taking up". On clay, I have seen the opposite sold as the same thing. The house was built on a dry site, the ground wet up, and part of the building rose. The low side looks like settlement. It never fell. Pinning that side, or pumping it up, makes the distortion worse.

Filler does not separate those. It hides the crack I would have used to show you which one you have.

Do not let the warranty be the monitoring period

The warranty is a deadline for the builder. It is different in each state. It is not a period in which every crack is normal. A crack in the last year of cover is not settlement because someone can still be sent to fill it.

I would rather have levels at the start and a photo of the crack before it is patched. When the warranty ends, the same crack is yours, and the record of how it opened is under the paint. Ask whether it has stopped. A return visit with filler is not an answer.

What I would do in the first week

  1. 1. Get a floor level survey at handover. That is the baseline. Every later argument is against those numbers, not against a story.
  2. 2. Photograph the cracks before anyone fills them. Tape or a coin in the shot, and the date. Write down whether the doors and cabinets are square. A photo after filler tells you nothing.
  3. 3. If it comes back, compare it with the baseline. A crack that reopens is not a second coat of settlement. Look at the whole house, not the patch.
  4. 4. If one visit still cannot tell you, leave something on the wall. Daily monitoring shows a corner that is still dropping, or a house that is rising, against a crack that opened once and stopped.

I inspect in Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney and Perth. I do not sell underpinning or resin injection. I will not tell you the builder is in breach, and I will not run the warranty claim. I will tell you whether the levels have changed, and whether the house was built that way.

Rob Voyle, Ground Movement Australia

Questions people ask

Do all new houses settle?

A new house can move a little while the building dries out and the ground takes its weight. That is not the same as every crack being settlement, and it is not a reason to keep filling cracks until the warranty ends. A sloping floor is not proof either. Houses less than a year old can be 120 mm out from one end to the other because they were built that way. Baseline levels, taken early, are how you separate that from movement since handover.

The floor is out of level. Has the house settled?

Not on one set of levels. I have levelled houses under 12 months old that were more than 120 mm out from one end to the other, with the door frames and cabinetry still level. Those houses were built to the slab. They did not drop after the kitchen went in. You need a baseline at handover, and a later survey against it. The second set is the one that shows movement.

The builder sent someone to fill the cracks. Is that a fix?

Filler is a repair of the surface. It is not a finding about the ground. If the crack was still opening, the filler hides the evidence until it splits again. Ask for the width, the date, and whether anyone took levels. If the answer is no, the visit was maintenance.

How long does natural settlement last?

There is no fixed period that covers every house. Early movement from drying and from the ground taking load is usually an early thing, and it should be getting smaller, not starting again each season. A builder's warranty runs for a set time, and that time is different in each state. The warranty clock is not a settlement period. A crack in year three is not settlement because the warranty has not ended.

CallEnquire